DEAN NATHAN - Hot Springs - Meats Evaluation - South Dakota Newell CDE

JudgingCard.com Results Events Individual Scorecard

South Dakota Newell CDE
Mar 11, 2026
Meats Evaluation

Overall

ID:	112 - 1 -
Team Name:	Hot Springs
Participant Name:	DEAN NATHAN
Individual Rank:	3
Individual Total Score:	320
Team Rank:	2
Team Total Score:	913
View e-Scansheet

Definition

Responses

Score

Placing Class 1

Part	Contestant	Judge
1	1423	4231

Placing 1 - Cut A	3
Placing 1 - Cut B	4
Placing 1 - Cut C	6

Placing Class 2

Part	Contestant	Judge
2	2134	2314

Placing 2 - Cut A	3
Placing 2 - Cut B	4
Placing 2 - Cut C	2

Placing Class 3

Part	Contestant	Judge
3	1243	2431

Placing 3 - Cut A	2
Placing 3 - Cut B	2
Placing 3 - Cut C	4

Placing Class 4

Part	Contestant	Judge
4	4312	4231

Placing 4 - Cut A	4
Placing 4 - Cut B	2
Placing 4 - Cut C	3

Placing Sum

142

Questions on Placing Classes

Part	Contestant	Judge
1	1	1
2	4	3
3	3	2
4	1	1
5	3	3

Questions - Points per Question

Quality Grading

Part	Contestant	Judge
1	Quality: High Standard	Quality: High Select
2	Quality: Average Prime	Quality: High Choice
3	Quality: High Prime	Quality: Low Choice
4	Quality: High Standard	Quality: High Select

Quality Grading - Maturity	A
Quality Grading - Maturity	A
Quality Grading - Maturity	A
Quality Grading - Maturity	A
Quality Grading - Maturity	A
Quality Grading - Maturity	A

Yield Grading

Part	Contestant	Judge
1	4.5	2.5
2	1.3	3.3
3	1.0	1.6
4	4.2	1.9

Carcass Grading Total

Written Exam

Part	Contestant	Judge
1	B	A
2	B	B
3	A	A
4	B	A
5	D	A
6	C	C
7	B	D
8	D	B
9	A	A
10	B	C
11	B	D
12	C	C
13	B	C
14	B	D
15	B	D
16	C	A
17	D	D
18	B	B
19	C	C
20	A	A
21	B	D
22	D	A
23	C	B
24	D	D
25	A	B
26	A	A
27	A	A
28	A	A
29	A	B
30	B	B

Written Exam - Points per Question

Formulation Solution

Part	Contestant	Judge
1		03

Formulation Solution - Points per Question

Formulation Questions

Part	Contestant	Judge
1		D
2		B
3		A
4		E
5		B
6		D
7		B

Formulation Questions - Points per Question

Meat ID 1-5

Part	Contestant	Judge
1	Species: Beef Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 78 - Variety - Liver Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 78 - Variety - Liver Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
2	Species: Beef Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 76 - Variety - Heart Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 76 - Variety - Heart Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
3	Species: Pork Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 85 - Various - Ground Pork Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 85 - Various - Ground Pork Cookery: Dry Heat
4	Species: Beef Primal: F - Loin Retail: 61 - Steaks - Top Round Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Beef Primal: F - Loin Retail: 59 - Steaks - Top Loin Steak Cookery: Dry Heat
5	Species: Lamb Primal: E - Ham or Leg Retail: 88 - Various - Shank Cookery: Moist Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 88 - Various - Shank Cookery: Moist Heat

Meat ID - Points per Species	1
Meat ID - Points per Primal	2
Meat ID - Points per Retail	3
Meat ID - Points per Cookery	1

Meat ID 6-10

Part	Contestant	Judge
6	Species: Beef Primal: D - Flank Retail: 91 - Smoked/Cured - Ham (Bnls) Cookery: Moist Heat	Species: Beef Primal: I - Round Retail: 08 - Roasts - Bottom Round Roast (Bnls) Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
7	Species: Lamb Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 50 - Steaks - Ribeye, Lip-On Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 71 - Chops - Rib Chop Cookery: Dry Heat
8	Species: Pork Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 80 - Variety - Tongue Cookery: Moist Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 80 - Variety - Tongue Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
9	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 60 - Steaks - Top Loin (Bnls) Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Beef Primal: I - Round Retail: 46 - Steaks - Eye Round Steak Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
10	Species: Beef Primal: B - Brisket Retail: 89 - Smoked/Cured - Brisket, Corned Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Beef Primal: B - Brisket Retail: 89 - Smoked/Cured - Brisket, Corned Cookery: Moist Heat

Meat ID - Points per Species	1
Meat ID - Points per Primal	2
Meat ID - Points per Retail	3
Meat ID - Points per Cookery	1

Meat ID 11-15

Part	Contestant	Judge
11	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 59 - Steaks - Top Loin Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 93 - Smoked/Cured - Loin Chop Cookery: Dry Heat
12	Species: Pork Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 95 - Smoked/Cured - Rib Chop Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 71 - Chops - Rib Chop Cookery: Dry Heat
13	Species: Beef Primal: K - Side (Belly) Retail: 15 - Roasts - Flat Half (Bnls) Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Beef Primal: I - Round Retail: 43 - Steaks - Bottom Round Steak Cookery: Moist Heat
14	Species: Lamb Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 78 - Variety - Liver Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 77 - Variety - Kidney Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
15	Species: Beef Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 22 - Roasts - Rib Roast Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: A - Breast Retail: 24 - Roasts - Ribs (Denver Style) Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat

Meat ID - Points per Species	1
Meat ID - Points per Primal	2
Meat ID - Points per Retail	3
Meat ID - Points per Cookery	1

Meat ID 16-20

Part	Contestant	Judge
16	Species: Beef Primal: G - Plate Retail: 55 - Steaks - T-Bone Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Beef Primal: F - Loin Retail: 55 - Steaks - T-Bone Steak Cookery: Dry Heat
17	Species: Lamb Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 50 - Steaks - Ribeye, Lip-On Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 71 - Chops - Rib Chop Cookery: Dry Heat
18	Species: Pork Primal: E - Ham or Leg Retail: 94 - Smoked/Cured - Picnic (Whole) Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Pork Primal: E - Ham or Leg Retail: 96 - Smoked/Cured - Rump Portion Cookery: Dry Heat
19	Species: Beef Primal: F - Loin Retail: 49 - Steaks - Porterhouse Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 66 - Chops - Blade Chop Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
20	Species: Beef Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 79 - Variety - Oxtail Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Beef Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 79 - Variety - Oxtail Cookery: Moist Heat

Meat ID - Points per Species	1
Meat ID - Points per Primal	2
Meat ID - Points per Retail	3
Meat ID - Points per Cookery	1

Meat ID 21-25

Part	Contestant	Judge
21	Species: Pork Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 68 - Chops - Butterflied Chop (Bnls) Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 68 - Chops - Butterflied Chop (Bnls) Cookery: Dry Heat
22	Species: Lamb Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 23 - Roasts - Rib Roast (Frenched) Cookery: Moist Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: H - Rib or Rack Retail: 23 - Roasts - Rib Roast (Frenched) Cookery: Dry Heat
23	Species: Beef Primal: C - Chuck Retail: 26 - Roasts - Seven (7) Bone Roast Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat	Species: Beef Primal: D - Flank Retail: 47 - Steaks - Flank Steak Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat
24	Species: Pork Primal: K - Side (Belly) Retail: 99 - Smoked/Cured - Sliced Bacon Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: K - Side (Belly) Retail: 99 - Smoked/Cured - Sliced Bacon Cookery: Dry Heat
25	Species: Beef Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 83 - Various - Cubed Steak Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Beef Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 83 - Various - Cubed Steak Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat

Meat ID - Points per Species	1
Meat ID - Points per Primal	2
Meat ID - Points per Retail	3
Meat ID - Points per Cookery	1

Meat ID 26-30

Part	Contestant	Judge
26	Species: Beef Primal: G - Plate Retail: 26 - Roasts - Seven (7) Bone Roast Cookery: Moist Heat	Species: Beef Primal: C - Chuck Retail: 26 - Roasts - Seven (7) Bone Roast Cookery: Moist Heat
27	Species: Lamb Primal: E - Ham or Leg Retail: 25 - Roasts - Rump Portion Cookery: Moist Heat	Species: Lamb Primal: E - Ham or Leg Retail: 01 - Roasts - American Style Cookery: Dry Heat
28	Species: Lamb Primal: F - Loin Retail: 37 - Roasts - Top Loin Roast (Bnls) Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: F - Loin Retail: 34 - Roasts - Tenderloin (Whole) Cookery: Dry Heat
29	Species: Beef Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 82 - Various - Beef for Stew Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Beef Primal: N - Various Meats Retail: 82 - Various - Beef for Stew Cookery: Moist Heat
30	Species: Beef Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 78 - Variety - Liver Cookery: Dry Heat	Species: Pork Primal: M - Variety Meats Retail: 77 - Variety - Kidney Cookery: Dry or Moist Heat

Meat ID - Points per Species	1
Meat ID - Points per Primal	2
Meat ID - Points per Retail	3
Meat ID - Points per Cookery	1

Meat ID Sum

119

AWS100: Friday, March 20, 2026